Wednesday, October 1, 2025

Freedom with Hunger (674 words)

 

The dusty road cut through a nameless town in the heart of Madhya Pradesh. As a travelling sales representative, I was used to long journeys and short halts. That afternoon, weary and hungry, my junior and I stopped at a sweet shop that looked larger than the rest.

We ordered aloo parotta with curd. Soon, a boy appeared with two plates and tall glasses of water. He was no more than thirteen, frail, with sunken cheeks, his skin stretched tight over bone. His eyes were swollen, one ringed with the shadow of a recent beating. He lingered near our table but was silent. 

In Tamil, I whispered to my colleague, “This boy is being ill-treated. Look at his eye.”

The boy startled. In broken Tamil, he asked, “Are you from Tamil Nadu?”

“Yes,” I said, surprised. “How did you come here? What happened to you?”

Before he could answer, a coarse voice boomed. “Hey, Chotu! Stop talking! Take this chai!” The shop owner glared, and the boy scurried away. But as he passed, he murmured, “I am a slave here.”

Something inside me alerted. I ordered more kachoris, then lassi, just to keep him coming back. When he placed the glasses before us, I whispered, “Come outside later. We’ll wait in a blue Maruti car. Find an excuse.” He gave the faintest nod.

Later, he slipped into the car, glancing around like a hunted animal. In halting words, between sobs, his story spilt out.

His name was Vadivel. His parents had been lured from Tamil Nadu with the promise of good work, given ten thousand rupees as an advance to clear village debts. But when they arrived, they were trapped in a quarry. The loan, inflated with usurious interest, kept them in bondage. Wages were swallowed whole. They lived on scraps and exhaustion.

His mother, frail and coughing from the dust, died without medicine. His sister, only thirteen, was preyed upon by the quarry owner; shame and despair drove her to the well. His father, broken by grief and chest pain, collapsed one day on the rocks and never rose again.

Vadivel was shifted to the sweet shop. From four in the morning till midnight, he worked without pay. He was beaten for mistakes, watched by the owner’s men, and never free.

When I asked if he wanted to escape, his eyes lit up for the first time. We drove off with the windows drawn and by evening reached Bhopal. There, he spoke of his wish: to go to Chennai, to find work in a hotel, to build a new life.

I bought him clothes, a train ticket, and pressed three hundred rupees into his hand. “Chennai is vast and dangerous,” I warned. “Beware of bad company. Protect your freedom.” He left with a smile. I left with hope.

Months passed, and I had forgotten him.

On a trip to Madurai, I stopped in Chennai and visited my brother, a police inspector. In his station, as his wife was away. A boy sat in handcuffs, head bowed, shrinking from the constables’ blows. My brother ordered him taken aside. As they dragged him away, I caught his face.

"Vadivel!” I gasped.

At the sound of his name, he collapsed at my feet, weeping.

“Sir,” he sobbed, “you warned me. But I had no work. The money was gone. No one helped me. I begged; I starved. And one day, I stole a purse. I was caught. The slavery with food was better than freedom with hunger. I wish I had never left.”

My throat tightened. I told my brother the boy’s story. Moved, he promised to take Vadivel into his home, to give him a chance at something better. The case was dropped, being his first offence and the stolen purse was recovered.

Yet Vadivel’s words clung to me long after I left the station:

Slavery with food is better than freedom with hunger.

And I wondered, with a heaviness I could not shake, what kind of world we had built for children like him.

 

19 comments:

  1. Rama Sampath Kunar : so true - in the 1970s and 1980s we would find so many young boys working in tge restaurants in Metro cities. They lived a life of misery and an inbuilt hatred in them for rich masters who provided them food and shelter. They felt that no rich person could be kind hearted. A pity indeed. They saw the rich escape with huge crimes because of their connections and money and the poor little boys being severely punished for petty crimes. So well expressed in this short piece! Loved the you expressed yourself! Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  2. A serious issue and a point to ponder.

    Thank you for making us realize the pain of hunger

    Chitra

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well written. Very thought provoking. So many countries around the world were better off economically and politically. With independence, there is instability with governance, conflicts and desperate poverty.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Even today we find cunning job offers land people in quarries where they are treated as slaves. These things are happening because the employer and State government are in collusion.

    ReplyDelete
  5. And that is why, at Nidara-Children we have incorporated providing access to nutrition to children as per international guidelines. I am committed to ensuring that every child born in our beautiful country will have access to nutritional food to gain the happy childhood they deserve.

    ReplyDelete
  6. A complex social problem. There is no one solution that fits all such situations. No one, especially innocent and impressionable children, should never become victims of such social ills.
    (My latest post: It's not the dream, it's the drive)

    ReplyDelete
  7. A story that sets one into thinking about the social injustice that is being perpreted for ages all over the world and particularly in countries like us.
    I have even seen very poor people in prosperous countries: in New York and SanFrancisco in USA; have seen poor people begging in Leeds, UK.
    But haven't seen poor people in any cities in Japan; also haven't seen poor people begging in Sydney, Australia.
    It sets me into thinking about the real cause of poverty and how to overcome this.
    It's a very complex issue no doubt; but to my mind it is essentially the unbridled greed of the man. A country which would be able to somewhat control this greed by strong governance and an ethical education system, coupled with an appropriate social security system, may eventually be able establish a reasonably equitable society.
    Atin Biswas

    ReplyDelete
  8. A thought provoking read. Thank you for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Very well crafted story that is lived by so many. The contrast between freedom and food & shelter is the basis of political systems around the world. From guaranteeing (promising) food and shelter but not much else for everyone to guaranteeing freedom (exceptions apply) but not much else for anyone. That’s the choice for most of us. Then there are the rather privileged who are constantly free and full while we gawk in disbelief at their good fortune. (JJ)

    ReplyDelete
  10. The writer, in his signature style, penned a story on the harsh realities of life that could be told so poignantly!

    ReplyDelete
  11. The line 'slavery with food is better than freedom with hunger' set me thinking. I have read about poor and homeless people do some petty crime and get sent to jail, so that they get two meals a day and a roof over their heads. A very poignant story well told. I wouldn't even call it a story, but a chronicle of actual events. Vadivel was lucky as he was helped by the writer and his cop brother. What about the countless others who spiral into a cycle of crime and incarceration? - Thangam

    ReplyDelete
  12. The countless instances of blunt incidents seen around us are captured and penned in his unique style by the writer in this sad story. The positive side is that people are still around there to console and help in society.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Felt sad while reading. I have seen 10/12 year old boys, cleaning tables in hotels. I gave one boy ten rupees while leaving but i turned around later and noticed the bearer shouting at the boy and plucking the money from the boy. The boy was frail and I think he was working without eating anything since morning. But couldn't help him in any other way. Read about a man who was looking old coming out of the prison after serving 35 years for stealing a hundred rupees ....Hmmm...this is our world now.....Sandhya



    ReplyDelete
  14. Well-written and the underlying social commentary is incisive. We have built a world of 8 billion souls, in which, of the four quadrants, Slavery with food and slavery with hunger are the most populated, whereas there is an almost empty quadrant, abundance of both food and freedom that is hardly populated. Yet the means to provide both is there. Shame on us.

    Arvind Rajan

    ReplyDelete
  15. A heavy story with the moral posed as a question. But alas, there is no easy answer. In our busy lives, it’s easy to miss or ignore these clues, but I’m glad that your protagonist picked up on them twice! A reminder to slow down and build more empathy in our actions. — Deepak

    ReplyDelete
  16. That statement "slavery with food is better than freedom with hunger" is deeply problematic. It reduces human dignity to mere survival.

    ReplyDelete
  17. An extremely well narrated story which is so very close to truth and tugs on your heart's strings .....made me feel so helpless...... Meka

    ReplyDelete
  18. Indeed!

    Hunger is the cause of life, existence and movement in any life!

    Good one!

    Best wishes and warm regards
    Hemantha Kumar Pamarthy

    ReplyDelete